Nuisance barking is a pretty common concern amongst dog-owners; as much as we love our little furballs, they require proper training at a young age to ensure that they aren’t keeping you up all night with their incessant yapping.
Anti-bark collars can also be used to reduce or eliminate undesirable or unsafe behavior in dogs, such as food aggression or off-leash training.
While dog collars were fairly unpopular when they were first introduced, the leaps and bounds that technology has taken over the past few decades have translated into no-bark solutions that are safe, humane and more effective, all at the same time.
There are four types of no-bark collars — static, vibration, spray and electric collars. Each of these is suited to a particular type of dog, either by temperament, breed or size, and the trick is to make sure you take all of these factors into account while picking out a no-bark collar.
The most important thing to do, once you have identified the exact cause of your dog’s excessive barking, is to find the best bark collar model for your dog’s temperament and habits.
With the introduction of a slew of safety features and options, such as varying levels of stimulus intensity as a correction, it would be an understatement to say that there are many, very promising options out there.
We go into further detail regarding this later on in this piece, and highlight some of the best bark collars for training different kinds of dogs.
The sheer range of brands, features and models of no-bark collars can seem rather overwhelming at first glance, but worry not.
Whether this is your first time training a dog to reduce his or her incessant barking, or you are an experienced trainer, brushing up on the mainstays of choosing a dog collar is always worth it.
Before we take you through those crucial factors, we have put together a list of the best bark collars that have won us over with their impressive features:
Best Bark Collars We Vouch For
Our best bark collar reviews have been put together after much research and insight from experienced dog-owners, as well as professional trainers. Not only that, we have also tried them ourselves...that's right, tested on our own necks! What you wouldn't do to a human, you shouldn't do to a dog either, right? We have done most of the heavy lifting, so that you can take this information and use it to weigh your options carefully before coming to a final decision.
The qualities that we looked out for, in particular, were how customizable the anti-bark collar is for dogs of varying sizes and breeds, as well as the range of safety features they offer to ensure smooth sailing during the training process.
The idea, of course, is to successfully complete the training process in as short a duration as possible, with the minimum amount of correction required to curb excessive barking.
The duration and success levels of the training process can vary based on the cause of barking, the age of the dog, the type of bark collar being used, as well as the trainer and the surroundings in which the training is taking place. All of these factors need to be paid special attention to, so as to ensure the exercise is as stress-free and effective as possible.
Top Picks For Best Bark Collars
Take a look at five of our best bark collars that offer an impressive set of features, that can help turn the long nights of your canine friend’s barking into much quieter, more peaceful ones.
Winner: SportDOG Brand NoBark 10R Rechargeable Bark Control Collar
Of all the bark collars we have gone through, the NoBark 10R collar emerges as the overall winner, due to how versatile and customizable it is.
Equipped with ten different levels of static stimulus, this collar lets you choose your own training preference from three training modes: User-Selected, Progressive Correction or Temperament Learning.
While the first mode allows you to pick the correction level of static stimulus you want to be delivered, the second is touted as the “most humane” mode of the three. This is because the stimulus delivered begins at the lowest level, and is taken up a notch only if your dog barks within 30 seconds of the previous one.
Lastly, we have the temperament learning mode, which begins the correction process at the lowest level of stimulus, and bumps it up a notch every time your dog barks at a frequency higher in a span of 30 seconds.
The Perfect Bark sensor system consistently ensures that a correctional static, that is safe but annoying to the dog, is only triggered through the contact points; so only if both the sound of the dog’s bark as well as vibrations from his or her vocal cords are detected, does the correctional stimulus get delivered.
This radically cuts down on false and redundant corrections.
Available at a very reasonable price, given the value it offers, this bark collar is rechargeable; it takes four hours to charge to capacity, and can last up to six months at full charge.
This no-bark collar also comes with several built-in safety features that make it a good bet; the NoBark 10R is waterproof and submersible up to a depth of 25 feet — a crucial factor, if you are training an outdoor dog.
It is also equipped with an automatic safety shut-off, and each of the training modes has its own blinking differently-colored light. The collar automatically shuts off for 3 minutes in case your dog barks more than 15 times in 50 seconds, so you never have to worry about any sort of harm being done to your dog, even if you are not around.
To make sure you make the most of this highly-effective bark collar, we encourage you to ensure your dog’s bark collar is fitted properly onto his or her neck, so that it is comfortable as well as effective in picking up vibrations from the dog’s vocal cords.
Runner-up: PetSafe Elite Bark Control Collar
The PetSafe Elite Bark Control Collar comes in second in our list; it is the best bark collar for large dogs, with neck sizes up to 28" which weigh in at over 40 lbs.
The waterproof collar offers ten levels of progressive static stimulus as correctional measures targeting nuisance barking. The patented Perfect Bark Detection prevents false triggers by delivering the correction only if the sound of barking as well as vocal cord vibrations are detected from your dog wearing the collar.
The automatic safety shut-off is another key feature, which turns off this easy-to-use collar for three minutes if your dog barks more than 15 times within a span of 80 seconds. This collar, for which no programming is required, can be used in a range of settings — in the outdoors, in a kennel or in an open courtyard.
This bark collar begins by delivering a safe, but firm, correctional stimulus at low levels, and increases the intensity of the corrections only if the dog continues barking incessantly.
Several positive reviews vouch for the effectiveness of this collar, based on their experiences as a part of which nuisance barking was reduced, if not altogether eliminated. Most dogs quickly understand that their excessive barking is what is causing the corrections, and stop engaging in unwanted or unsafe behavior.
The in-built software of this collar also keeps track of the number of corrections required to cut down excessive barking, and remembers it during every leg of the training.
Another great thing about this collar is that you have customer support from US-based PetSafe employees six days a week, available over email, chat and call. When this collar is purchased from an authorized retailer, the customer also receives a valid manufacturer’s warranty.
Alternative Option #1: Petrainer Electric E-Collar
Whether you are buying a no-bark collar for your dog’s incessant barking, unwanted aggression or to correct other behavioral issues, this electronic collar is a worthy pick to get you and your dog through the training process.
With a remote range of up to 900 feet, this wireless dog collar can be used comfortably in a range of open spaces. Since the rechargeable transmitter and receiver can be charged simultaneously, you don’t have to worry about running out of battery mid-training.
With static stimulation and vibration stimulus that can be customized according to your preference, this collar offers the trainer a whopping 100 levels of customizations, as well as a standard beeping tone mode that emits a noise as a warning to ensure that your dog is delivered the level of stimulation required to cut down on the excessive barking.
Waterproof and equipped with a TPU collar strap that can be adjusted, this bark collar can fit dogs of any size weighing more than 10 lbs. This one is a favorite amongst professional trainers and new pet-owners alike as an effective bark control solution and comes out on top as the best bark collar for small dogs, the best waterproof dog training collar and best remote dog collar.
Alternative Option #2: Dogtra YS300 Dog Collar
Dogtra has really hit it out of the park with this smart, non-submersible dog collar that is total value for money. Equipped with a sound-recognition and filtering microprocessor, this anti-bark collar can differentiate a dog’s barking from external or ambient noises, responding only to the former, and avoiding redundant corrections.
This collar works well for sensitive dogs of varying sizes and delivers a non-electrical vibration stimulus as a precursor to the actual correction. This collar recognizes that different dogs have varying temperaments and offers six varying levels of intensity, so that you can sniff out what suits your dog best.
The surgical stainless steel contact points and anti-microbial plastic that constitute this collar make it extremely safe for your dog’s skin, and reduces the chances of sores appearing on his or her neck.
You can recharge this lightweight, waterproof collar in two hours flat, and it also comes with a one-year warranty and a guarantee of satisfaction within the first month.
Alternative Option #3: Garmin Delta Sport Dog Training Device
Our last pick in our list of the best anti-bark collars gives you a good bang for your buck. Recommended by professional trainers fairly often, the Garmin Delta Sport Dog Training Device is a compact and durable device that uses rechargeable lithium-ion batteries that can last up to three months at full charge.
These waterproof (IPX7) devices are equipped with stainless steel contact points which have been optimized for a variety of dog breeds and coat lengths, making them suitable for training most dogs.
With the purchase of this no bark-collar, you could be one step closer to eliminating nuisance barking and paving your way to a calmer home with your canine friend.
The innovative BarkLimiter is another feature that makes this collar stand out, as it utilizes advanced bark correction technology to correct undesirable behavior. This only works when used with the Delta Sport Replacement Handheld Training Device, which you have to buy separately.
Alternative Option #4: PetSafe Gentle Spray Bark Collar
To add to our list of the best anti-bark collars, we wanted to also give you a less effective yet popular alternative, especially for smaller dogs - PetSafe Gentle Spray Bark Collar. This no bark-collar uses a burst of citronella spray to discourage barking. The spray is a stain-free hypo-allergenic non-toxic citrus spray, but it can also be substituted for an unscented spray. This also means that you need to refill the collar every 25-30 sprays, and the can will last you 300-400 sprays. You will also need to replace a one 6-volt alkaline battery once in a while.
This no bark-collar is water resistant - meaning that it can take light rain or wet grass exposure. It is also lightweight and designed specifically for dogs with neck sizes up to 24".
From the drawbacks, the microphone on the back of the unit is sometimes too sensitive and may give the dog a stimulation when he or she is not barking. Otherwise, this bark collar has plenty of positive reviews.
Spray bark collars are reportedly less effective than the static stimulation collars, but much more effective than the ultrasonic collars, they are also light and designed for dogs weighting at or over 6 lbs, making them a great choice for smaller dogs.
Alternative Option #5: Pet Convincer Air Blast
Although this tool is not a collar, we decided to include it here, since it offers a nice humane alternative bark solution. The Pet Convincer uses acoustic and air effects to disrupt the unwanted barking once it occurs. You will need to direct the Pet Convincer at your dog's shoulder and push the lever to release a "convincing" air flow. In order for this device to work, you will need to stay at a maximum distance of 8 inches away from the dog. The manufacturer recommends using short - one second - air bursts for behavior correction. You can find videos showing how to use this device on our YouTube channel.
This device is designed to be used with almost any breed, however, since every dog is different, you will have to try it to figure out if it works for your pooch. Remember to never point the Pet Convincer towards your dog's face, eyes, or rectum. In terms of the drawbacks, similar to spray collars, you will need to replace Pet Convincer's cartridges, those will usually emit 15-30 bursts each, after which you will need to buy more directly from the manufacturer's website at www.petconvincer.com. Unlike the other bark control solutions, you will not be able to use it if your dog barks while you are away, or at a distance, and you will need to carry this device with you wherever you go. Despite the drawbacks, it can serve as an effective alternative bark control solution that is humane and cost-effective.
The Importance Of Picking The Best Bark Collar For Your Dog
When it comes to choosing the best bark collar for your furry friend, it is just not worth compromising either on quality or research. As each dog has different inclinations, and his or her own temperament, one size does not fit all.
So how do you begin the process of looking for the best-suited dog bark collar for you and your dog?
Knowing your dog and his or her habits well is a good place to start your lookout for the best bark collar, so you can zero in on an option that can be customized to your training preferences.
Taking into account factors such as how sensitive your dog is and the most common reason he or she barks incessantly can be instrumental in helping you pick the best-suited bark-deterrent collar.
The training process and environment need to be carefully monitored so as to ensure that only the required level of correction is delivered to your dog and that no mishap occurs. The idea is to cut down on the incessant barking, not startle the dog to an extent that he or she cannot even associate the correction with the barking.
Taking the advice of a professional trainer, vet or experience dog-owner is always helpful in the comparison of bark collars. With proper guidance in training a dog with excessive barking or behavioral issues, the process can be a smooth and quick one with minimum discomfort to the dog.
Factors To Consider When Choosing Your Bark Collar
Choosing the best bark collar for your dog is not something to be taken lightly; there are a range of factors that need to be taken into account to figure out the anti-bark collar that would best suit your dog, in particular.
Here are some of the primary factors you need to factor in when intelligently picking out a no-bark collar:
As mentioned in our introductory piece on anti-bark dog collars, there are essentially four types to choose from, varying only in terms of the correctional stimuli they deliver as a correction.
The four types are static, ultrasonic, spray and vibrating collars, and it is really the disposition of your dog, such as how sensitive he or she is, that should determine the type of collar you choose to go with.
The spray collars, for instance, are considered to be the most “humane”, although they do come with a longer training period. Ultrasonic bark collars, too, cause a minimum amount of discomfort to your dog, while emitting high-frequency noises that help reduce incessant barking.
Vibrating and static bark collars have come a long way since being launched; with the development of technology, these collars have introduced varying intensities of correction, so you can choose what suits your dog best. These have come to be known as some of the most effective dog collars that deliver results quickly.
A no-bark collar needs to fit securely against your dog’s throat, as most modern devices today pick up not just on the barking of the dog, but also the vibrations from their vocal cords.
This is a great feature, as it prevents external noises, ambient sounds or the barking of another dog from triggering a correction and confusing the dog that is being trained.
Choosing the right size in bark collars for your dog is also incredibly important as a no-bark collar that is fitted too tightly would result in painful sores on the poor dog’s neck, whereas a bark collar that is too loose would not pick up on the vocal cord vibrations effectively enough.
It is best if you have your dog fitted with his or her anti-bark collar by a professional, veterinarian or experienced dog-owner so that it is secure and comfortable for the training process.
The safety of your dog, naturally, always takes priority during the training process. Most modern anti-bark collars come equipped with an array of safety features that make using them an easy and stress-free affair.
Safety features such being waterproof or submersible ensure that you can keep track of outdoor dogs, even if they have wandered far away.
Developments in technology have also translated into more options for the trainer or dog owner, such as varying levels of correction intensity, which can be optimized to the disposition of your dog and his or her surroundings.
The automatic shut-off feature is another one that is popular amongst dog-lovers, as it switches the device off in case the dog barks multiple times in a short, stipulated duration of time. This ensures that the device does not malfunction, and your dog is safe at all times.
The material of the bark collar, how it is fitted around the dog’s neck and the bark collar model’s suitability for that particular size and breed of dog are all factors that contribute to how comfortable the anti-bark collar is for the dog.
The type of correction that is used also factors into the comfort level of the training process, and it is important to pick the right one so that you don’t find yourself “barking up the wrong tree”, so to speak.
While ultrasonic and spray no-bark collars are better suited for sensitive dogs, or those who have exhibited anxiety or insecurity in the past, static or electric collars with varying intensities are considered to be the most effective in reducing nuisance barking.
The idea is to make the dog associate the correction with his or her excessive barking as quickly as possible, with the least amount of discomfort, so as to help create quieter homes with more peaceful pets.
Teaching A Dog New Tricks
There is a delicate mix of research, quality technology and an intuitive understanding of your own dog that factor into picking out the best bark collar for him or her. With options such as varying intensities of correctional stimuli available today, it is possible to customize your anti-bark collar so as to best suit the disposition of your furry friend.
For instance, a dog with a history of separation anxiety or insecurity cannot be delivered high-intensity electric stimuli — this would startle the poor creature, and he might possibly stop barking altogether, as has been observed in a few cases.
Each of the various types of bark-deterrent dog collars — static, vibration, spray and electric — come with their own benefits and drawbacks. It is only through thorough research and a deep understanding of your dog that you can figure out which would make for the best fit.
By gaining insight from individuals and professionals who have a deeper knowledge of bark-control solutions, you can choose a device that suits your dog’s temperament and inclinations well, to make the training process a much smoother affair.
While your dog need not wear the collar once the association between the correction with his or her effusive barking has formed, some dogs do “rebel” and need retraining after a few weeks.
Special attention to safety features and comfort will ensure that the purpose of the exercise is served; after all, the idea is to reduce the incessant barking of your dog through a minimum level of discomfort caused to him or her.